Papers of BAS

Reading Сommittee

Instructions for reviewers: Please assess the article that you have received in the terms provided on this sheet. If you feel that you cannot provide such commentary in our peer review, please return the essay to us to be sent out to a different scholar.

Please fill in the form below:

BULGARIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES

PAPERS of BAS. HUMANITIES & SOCIAL SCIENCES JOURNAL

1040 Sofia, 1 15 Noemvri

Editor in chief: Prof. Vassil Nikolov, Corresponding Member of BAS

vassil.nikolov@abv.bg

PEER REVIEW FORM

Title of paper:

Reviewer:

Email Address:

Date:


Please highlight the answer that most fully reflects your opinion

1. The paper is in line with the journal's profile:

Completely

Partly

No

2. The paper considers a legitimate research problem and contributes to its solution:

Completely

Partly

No

3. This work is new and original research:

Completely

Partly

No

4. The paper contains clearly formulated aims, methodology and conclusions:

Completely

Partly

No

5. The paper contributes to development of knowledge in the research filed:

Completely

Partly

No

6. The paper has a logical and adequate organization:

Completely

Partly

No

7. The data are presented accurately and clearly:

Completely

Partly

No

8. The interpretations and conclusions are sound and justified by the data:

Completely

Partly

No

9. The paper is clear and readable; style and language are acceptable:

Completely

Partly

No

10. Tables (if any) are clear, accurate and related to the text:

Completely

Partly

No

11. Figuresif any) are of good quality, clear, informative and related to the text:

Completely

Partly

No

12. All the tables and figures in the text are present:

Yes

No

13. The title reflects the content of the paper:

Completely

Partly

No

14. The references are complete, accurate, up-to-date and related to the text:

Completely

Partly

No

15. The abstract is concise and informative:

Completely

Partly

No

16. Your recommendation to the Editorial Board:

  • Accept the paper in its present form
  • Accept the paper with minor revisions.
  • The paper should be heavily edited / rewritten.
  • Reject the paper.

17. Comments and recommendations to the Editorial Board:

………….

18. Comments and recommendations to the author:

………….